American Egyptomania Search

Gerome: Introductory and Critical

Gerome: A Collection of the Works of J.L. Gerome in One Hundred Photgravures. Multiple Volumes. New York: Samuel L. Hall, 1881.

Browse scholarship by topic:

Art & Architecture


mate composition, of daring choice, of incisive relevancy, of memorable in fluence.

These pictures are painted in the manner of the grand stylists, without the least concession to the painters of "bits,' who turn all question of merit into the treatment of still-life or bric-á-brac. To these he is as deaf as was Ingres, or David, or Michael Angelo, or Leonardo. I am not saying which coterie is right, and I appreciate as highly as any one the marvels of the "morceau," as represented by able realists. But I have observed that epic poets have a different choice of words from vernacular and dialect poets, and I do not look in the pages of my Dante for the terms of Pulcinello. I have observed that the best old frescoes discard bric-á-brac representation; that Raphael, even when he prepares so small an easel picture as the "Vision of Ezekiel;' adheres to his grand statuesque manner, his reticence of trivial statements or facts about texture. I observe that Baudry, decorating the Opera, goes to Rome for years to catch "le pli de Michel-Ange," and comes back, painting texturelessly without blame. In his case this seems to be accepted as a concomitant of the grand style. At the present day. easel -pictures must be painted, and not grand walls or big altarpieces. Perhaps, on reflection, the critics will kindly allow these to be executed sometimes in the grand manner, with the Dantean or Leonardesque choice of terms, as kindly as they allow Raphael's little "Ezekiel" to be so painted, or Baudry's great ceiling.

I enjoy with all my capacity the works of the greater realists, and when a bit of execution conies before me that just hits a nail on the head—gives me a "bit" happily mastered, a texture luckily imitated, a scheme of values maintained to the point of illusion—no spectator is more delighted But I have had the pleasure, on the other hand, of studying certain temperaments, and from what I observe of the. methods by which the bric-á-brac painters work, I am certain that there are minds that would never stoop to their successes. Gerome, I am convinced, would hardly care to learn the tricks of texture, if they must be got with devices, or by the use of implements, that would make him lose absolute control over his drawing at every point. If the public knew the arts by which texture is commonly got—the wiping away of bitumen with rags, the notching of flat brushes into something like garden-rakes, the scratching. with sacks and matches, the waiting for megilp to get tacky, and then the torture of it into superb effects; the

Page 6